Monday, April 30, 2007

Consumer Spending Decreases .2% In March

From the AP:

The Commerce Department reported that consumer spending on all items was up 0.3 percent last month, the slowest increase since a similar rise in October. Incomes rose by 0.7 percent, the fourth straight solid month of income growth.

The spending performance was even weaker when the effects of higher gasoline prices were removed. After adjusting for price increases, consumer spending actually fell by 0.2 percent in March, the poorest showing since the fall of 2005 when the economy was suffering the aftershocks of Hurricane Katrina.


From Bloomberg:

``I would expect, especially if gas prices continue to push higher, that consumers are not going to be contributing nearly as much'' to economic growth, Chris Low, chief economist at FTN Financial, said before the report.

.....

``The rise in gasoline prices ate up the gains in nominal spending,'' said James O'Sullivan, senior economist at UBS Securities LLC in Stamford, Connecticut. ``Everything points to a much weaker consumer in the second quarter.''


This is one of the main reasons I focus a great deal of attention on gasoline prices. It's a price consumers have to pay, usually at least once a week. It's also a vital expense. Consumers will buy gas pretty-much regardless of the economic circumstances. When gas prices increase, consumers may cut back on spending on other goods and services.

The drops in consumer spending occurred in non-durable goods and services. These sectors dropped by 2.8 billion and 13.2 billion in chained 2000 dollars.

The inflation numbers were mixed. CBS reported:

The core personal consumption expenditure price index was flat in March, bringing the year-over-year increase down to 2.1% from 2.4% in February. Economists had expected a 0.1% gain in the core PCE.

The downward direction on inflation is sure to please Fed officials, but the level remains above the central bank's inflation ceiling of 2%.

Total inflation rose 0.4% in March and is up 2.4% over the past year.


For those of you who don't consumer food or energy, you saw no price increases. For the rest of us, we saw an increase especially in oil. The price at the pump in Houston Texas (where I live) is just below $3.00/gallon for premium. And it's only the end of April.

It's important to add the Fed has been forecasting lower inflation from lower growth for nearly a year now. Inflation has remained above the Fed's comfort zone for most of this time. While it has dropped a bit it's still higher than the Fed would like. Conversely, it's also important to point out inflation has not gotten out-of-hand. It's just been very stubbornly hanging on to the 2% - 2.5% range for some time.

I still don't see the Fed lowering rates because of this. They have firmly come out on the side of fighting inflation at the expense of economic growth.

6 comments:

Anonymous said...

Hilarious,

When I read the PI report this morning I was sure that Bonddad would lead with the decline in spending.

Never mind that nominal personal incomes were up 9.2% in Q1 or that wage growth was strong. or that tax payments were even stronger.

You should change the name of your blog to 'All the Misery that's Fit to Blog'

bonddad said...

1.) Personal Incomes increased .7% -- not 9.7%. They increased from $11,309 trillion to $11,389 trillion.

2.) If you look at the latest GDP report, consumer spending is the only thing holding the economy in positive territory. That means any signs of consumer weakness means the only area of economic strength is weakening. That's not good.

3.) Taxes always increase this time of year because this is when people pay their taxes.

sterno said...

Here in Chicago I'm seeing $3.40 or so for regular. I have little doubt we'll be creeping over $4.00/gallon this summer.

Camille said...

Thanks for the blog Bonddad!

I think we're in for a summer of lousy numbers...

Anonymous said...

Personal Income for Q1 2007 was up 9.2% from a year ago. Sorry, I should have been more precise about the time period.

Tax receipts were up 17.2% in Q1 2007 from Q1 2006, presumably people were paying their taxes in 2006 at the same time as well. The AMT is getting more people and capital gains are adding to the total as well.

Seasonal adjustment is always dicey in March and April. All of the weakness was in services, my bet would be utilities due to unseasonably warm weather. One month does not a trend make. For all of Q1, real pce was up 3.8% and is up 3.4% from a year ago.

With incomes up as sharply as they are, the consumer is well positioned to keep on spending.

bonddad said...

The problem with the income level is the employment situation deteriorates rapidly right before and during the initial months of a recession.

Friday's report should be interesting to say the least. So long as there isn't a downward trend or shock the markets should be happy. Unemployment claims are still in good shape so I doubt we'll see a great deal of pain there.

The real wild card is construction and real estate employment.