Tuesday, January 25, 2011

More on Commodity Prices

From Bloomberg:

Cotton futures soared to a record on speculation that global supplies will fail to keep pace with rising demand in China, the world’s largest user.

Chinese imports surged 86 percent in 2010 as economic growth lifted demand from textile mills and adverse weather hurt the domestic crop. The country’s purchases may increase before next month’s Lunar New Year holidays, said Han Sung Min, a broker at Korea Exchange Bank Futures Co. On Jan. 12, the U.S. government cut its global-production outlook. Prices have more than doubled in the past year.

“Cotton was supported by China’s import data and speculation that the country will buy more” as the holidays approach, Seoul-based Han said.

From Bloomberg:

Wheat fell for the first day in six in Chicago on speculation that a rally to a five-month high will reduce demand from investors. Corn and soybeans also dropped.

Wheat gained 8 percent in the past five sessions on speculation adverse weather in South America, China and the U.S. curbed production. Hedge-fund managers and other large speculators pared their net-long position in Chicago wheat futures by 1 percent in the week ended Jan. 18, according to U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission data.

“Everybody is aware of the weather situations going on right now,” said Connor Noonan, an analyst with Castlestone Management in London. “Everybody has priced in the floods in Australia, and now we have flooding in South America. All of that combined, people are taking a little off the table.”

From Agrimoney:

The world faces another year of substantial wheat deficit in 2011-12, amid what is likely to be the "most intense battle for acres in history", Commonwealth Bank of Australia warned.

World wheat production, which is expected to fall 17m tonnes below consumption in the current season, will chalk up a second successive shortfall, reducing inventories to their lowest for four years.

Indeed, it will take until 2012-13 for the world to return to a, modest, surplus in wheat output, CBA said, pitching itself at the gloomier end of the round of forecasters releasing initial estimates for the coming season.

CBA forecast the 2011-12 deficit at 15m tonnes, noting that prospects for winter crops in the US and China had been curtailed by drought, while the likelihood of a rise in further seedings was being curbed by the clamour for nearly all crops for extra area to rebuild production and depleted supplies.

Notice that all the articles point to supply and demand issues: China increased its cotton imports 86% in a single year. That's a huge increase, and one that is large enough to drain world supplies. The wheat market is also suffering from supply issues. Also note that with increasing living standards, diets change, and hence people typically demand more food. In short, there are plenty of fundamental reasons for the increase in commodity prices, most of which are the result of increasing living standards.

4 comments:

Steve said...

Are there real reasons for price fluctuations? Yes. The big question in my mind though is how much of that fluctuation is genuinely driven by basic supply and demand concerns and how much of it is generated by all the cheap money sloshing around the system looking for a high rate of return?

Derivatives were originally conceived as a way to smooth out markets. By providing a way to project future supply/demand, it allows greater predictability. However what I see happening more is that derivatives trading is leading to quite the opposite situation. That is, the more volatile the market, the more profitable it is for the traders.

I can't prove that any of this is happening, but I know what the incentives say. The incentives say that if you can make a market and then get out of that market you can make a lot of money. You make money in buying low and selling high, and you make money on the transactions. Win win. The more volatile the market, the more trades, the more profit.

Anonymous said...

I don't know if you have looked into this or not, but does the world have enough capacity in these commodities to meet increasing demand or is increasing price the only brake on demand?

Jimdotz said...

bonddad, what you write is no doubt real, but speculation amplifies that reality to unrealistic levels.

Jimdotz said...

Ok, ok, ok... Even Krugman thinks you're basically right, bonddad: http://nyti.ms/gI6D8y

I'll capitulate now. Speculate away.